The 6 Best Bay Head NJ Vacation Rentals

by newjerseyshores | Oct 11, 2023

Bordered by the Atlantic Ocean on the east and Barnegat Bay on the west, Bay Head is the crown jewel of the Jersey Shore. With its pristine beaches, expansive waterfront views, and tight-knit community, it’s become a favorite destination for visitors looking for a peaceful retreat.

bay head nj vacation rentals

Aside from the beaches and the kind hospitality, Bay Head is also known for its architectural heritage. Some of its houses were built in the late 19th century, showcasing Victorian exteriors and intricate details.

If you’re looking for a peaceful but upscale beach house in Bay Head, we’ll help you choose your destination from the rental market. We have options for friends groups, families, and couples on our list.

Here’s a list of the best Bay Head NJ, vacation rentals:

Beach Block Rental House – For a Group of Friends

If you’re vacationing with a large group, take a look at this large beach house. It has six spacious bedrooms and five baths, which means you can enjoy it with your entire family or group of friends comfortably. 

The available beds are perfect for 12 guests, but they can fit more than 14 guests with some adjustments. However, it’s worth noting that the minimum age allowed in the property is 25 years old.

There’s WiFi available throughout the house, and the amenities are quite decent considering the house’s size. The hosts provide bed pillows, blankets, and bedspreads. On top of that, they provide all bathroom necessities, along with Keurig coffee pods and coffee pot filters.

The kitchen has a coffee maker, a stove with an oven, a microwave, a blender, a dishwasher, and a toaster. So, needless to say, you’ll have everything you need!

Aside from the amenities, the house’s location is ideal for beach access. It’s located one block north of Bay Head, on the Southern side of Point Pleasant Beach. Only one house stands between this one and the beach—a 200-feet distance.

Plus, the hosts provide 12 beach chairs, badges, and umbrellas, so you don’t have to carry your own.


  • Close to the beach
  • Restaurants and leisure activities available nearby
  • Pets are allowed inside
  • An outdoor pool is available

Classic BayHeader – For the Family

If you’re traveling with the whole family, you’ll love this classic Bay Header with its spacious interiors and multiple bedrooms. It includes five bedrooms and three bathrooms for plenty of privacy.

It’s a family-oriented house that you can visit with parents, grandparents, and kids. However, no pets are allowed, which may be an inconvenience for some visitors. The available amenities make up for it, though.

The house has a wrap-around porch with doors on both ends. Its main floor has an open-floor design with an eat-in kitchen, and the kitchen’s slider oversees a separate porch.

The hosts don’t provide bedding, so you’ll have to bring your own. However, the amenities available make up for it. The house has a central AC, and WiFi is available throughout. On top of that, there’s an onsite parking area in case you bring your rental car.

The house is only two blocks away from Bridge Ave Beach, a walking distance. Additionally, it’s close to many food places, including Dune Grass Cafe and Mueller’s Bakery.


  • Air conditioning available
  • No pets allowed
  • An onsite parking area is available
  • A walking distance from the NJ Transit train station

Beach Block Apartment – For Small Groups

If houses aren’t your thing, check out this Bay Head apartment only one block away from the beach. It sleeps eight persons comfortably in three bedrooms, and it has two bathrooms for privacy. Plus, there’s free WiFi, which is a bonus.

However, we’d argue that the best thing about this apartment is the air conditioning available. It certainly helps in New Jersey’s hot summers!

The place includes a kitchen, a dryer, a washer, and two bathrooms with basic necessities (towels, etc.) available. The hosts don’t allow smoking, pets, or parties on the property, so it’d be wise to check the rules before booking to make sure they suit you. Children are allowed, so you don’t have to worry about that.

The house is a 3-minute drive from Joe’s Bagel & Grill Point Pleasant and a 6-minute walk from Mueller’s Bakery, so you won’t have to worry about getting food. Plus, if you crave some ice cream during your vacation, Hoffman’s Ice Cream is available at only a 3-minute drive.


  • No pets allowed
  • Safety features are available on the property, including a smoke detector and a fire extinguisher
  • A jetted bathtub is available in the master bathroom
  • Only a 2-minute walk from Bay Head Beach

The Sea Loft – For Couples

If you’re traveling alone or with a partner, The Sea Loft is the perfect rental property for you. It’s not family-oriented; there’s only one bedroom, so it’s only suitable for couples and single visitors.

The open-space loft has a cozy bedroom with a queen bed, along with a lounge area consisting of a coffee table, a couch, and a TV. There’s a private bathroom with a clawfoot tub, and the rest of the space includes a breakfast bar with a mini fridge. And in case you love your morning coffee, there’s a Keurig coffee maker.

Guests are welcome to the loft, and they can enjoy the shared space on the first floor, which includes a kitchen and a bath. They can also enjoy the patio and outdoor shower.

The best part about the Sea Loft is its location, which is only an hour away from the Newark Airport. It’s close to the beach, lying on the Jersey shore, and the host provides beach bikes in case you love summer rides.


  • All reviewers praised the host and his hospitality
  • Washer, dryer, workspace, a modern kitchen, and WiFi are available on the property
  • Air conditioning is available
  • Onsite parking available

The Butterfly Cottage – For Couples With Guests

The Butterfly Cottage is the ultimate summer escape as its hosts like to call it. It’s the perfect beach house for couples looking for a peaceful retreat, and its size allows for guests.

The house is adequately sized with one bedroom, one bathroom, and central air conditioning. With beautiful hardwood floors, stainless steel kitchen appliances, and an outdoor patio, it’s the perfect embodiment of upscale vacation homes.

The outdoor patio includes a four-seater table with an umbrella, so you can host guests while renting the house. They’ll have access to the house and all its utilities, which include WiFi, barbecue grills, beach badges, bikes, a Keurig coffee maker, and a toaster oven.

The house also has a private driveway, so you can keep your rental car close.

The Butterfly Cottage is pretty close to popular attractions. It’s a 5-minute bike ride away from Bay Head Beach and Point Pleasant Beach. So, it’s one of the best locations you can get at Bay Head.

Its rate may be higher than the average price range, but with central air conditioning, a private backyard, a private beach, and amazing views, it provides decent value for money.


  • Free onsite parking is available
  • Pets are allowed
  • Central air conditioning
  • A private, fully-fenced backyard is available

The Cozy Clam Shell – For Couples/Single Visitors

The Cozy Clam Shell is another rental property that’s fit for couples and single visitors. It only includes one bedroom, but it offers pretty decent amenities considering its price range. It doesn’t allow pets, partially because the space isn’t large enough for four-legged friends to strut around.

The house is close to plenty of popular attractions, including The Bluff’s Beach, which is only one block away. And for the guest’s convenience, the host provides two bikes and beach chairs. If you want a beach badge, you can get it at the BHIA.

The Cozy Clam Shell includes all the basic necessities you need in a vacation rental, including a washer, a dryer, a TV, a kitchen, WiFi throughout the house, and air conditioning. There’s also free parking available on the property.

Guests who rented the house praised the cleanliness and the modern furnishing of the rental, despite the fact that it was built in 1904 and is considered a historic property. They were also thankful for the seamless self-check-in process that doesn’t require any contact with anybody.


  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Beach access and free parking are available
  • Self-check-in available with only the lockbox

Reserve Your Bay Head NJ Vacation Rentals

A vacation at Bay Head, NJ is exactly what you need during this hot summer! The Victorian houses, the waterfront views, and the pristine beaches will help you retreat into a peaceful state of mind without an ounce of stress.

If you’re traveling with the entire family, the Classic Bayheader is what you’re looking for with its spacious rooms and multiple baths. Meanwhile, this Beach Block Rental is more suited for a group of friends. It also allows pets, which is a bonus.

If you’re on a romantic getaway with your partner, either the Sea Loft or the Butterfly Cottage will be perfect for the vacation.