Where To Eat in Belmar New Jersey

by newjerseyshores | Aug 17, 2023

Have you been granted a precious period of respite to savor the joys of an exquisite gastronomic voyage to the coastal area of Belmar? This is your chance to experience all this stunning region offers and take a well-deserved break away from your daily life. Enjoy all the delicious seafood delights and unique flavors in this captivating destination.

places to eat in belmar new jersey

If you are considering a trip to Belmar, why not gather your friends and family and enjoy the finest dining by consulting this carefully compiled selection of top restaurants in Belmar? Make sure to prepare for an unforgettable experience. With so many delicious options available, you can rest assured that you will find something to satisfy everyone’s taste buds.

Explore dining options with picturesque waterfront views, lively bars, catering services for any event, delicious platters to share, and much more. We have also included outstanding options from all over the city, including cafes, seafood joints, gastropubs, pizzerias, and many other types of cuisine. Don’t wait any longer; start planning your unforgettable culinary journey now!

Avon Pavilion

The Avon Pavilion is a premier, exquisite restaurant located on the boardwalk of the beautiful beachfront in the charming neighboring town of Avon-By-The-Sea. It offers its guests an unforgettable dining experience where they can enjoy delicious meals while taking in the stunning views of the ocean. From romantic dinners to family gatherings, The Avon Pavilion is always ready to offer its visitors a unique and memorable experience.

If you have been looking to relive the luxurious fine dining experience you had in Belmar, look no further than the Avalon Pavilion. Here, you can indulge in an exquisite selection of culinary delights that will please even the pickiest of food connoisseurs.

With a wide variety of delicious dishes and flavors, attentive service and a stunning atmosphere, your time at the Avalon Pavilion will be one you won’t forget soon!

This sophisticated eatery boasts beautifully plated dishes, an upscale interior with stunning decor, and a relaxed ambiance. It offers an extensive all-day menu of appetizing dishes and a constantly changing selection of daily specials. The elegant atmosphere is complemented by the laid-back vibe, making it the perfect place for any occasion – from casual catch-ups to special celebrations.

Start your day by treating yourself to an amazing Veggie Homefries Au Gratin Platter. It’s filled with diced peppers, broccoli, melted cheddar cheese, freshly cut potatoes, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, and Monterey jack for a truly delicious meal.

For dinner, opt for the exquisite Filet Mignon Remy. This twelve-ounce dry-aged beef tenderloin is sure to please any discerning palate, accompanied by thyme-grilled asparagus, a delectable gorgonzola butter, and savory souffléd asiago potatoes.

600 N Ocean Ave
Avon-By-The-Sea, NJ 07717
(732) 775-1043

Mr. Shrimp

Mr. Shrimp is a much-lauded, all-encompassing eatery emphasizing seafood dishes. It offers an extensive variety of delectable fish selections, making it popular among diners who appreciate fresh and flavourful cuisine. With its impeccable service and mouthwatering menu, Mr. Shrimp has earned its reputation as one of the town’s most renowned full-service dining establishments.

Offering personalized menus and packages to suit your budget and appetite, Mr. Shrimp in Belmar is an excellent choice for celebrating birthdays. Furthermore, it provides catering services for special occasions with a party room with its own entrance, private bathroom, and adjustable layout.

The establishment’s maritime-inspired interior has a chill atmosphere and knowledgeable staff.

The Steamed Lobster Dinner is a house specialty that should not be missed. An impressive plate of split Maine lobster accompanied by drawn butter, corn on the cob, coleslaw made in-house, and more await you. To round out your seafood experience, consider also trying the Seafood Fra Diavolo.

1608 NJ-71
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 681-7755

Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant

Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant has been a staple in the community for over two decades. Since its establishment more than 20 years ago, it has continued to serve delicious pizza that keeps locals and visitors alike coming back time and again. This beloved pizza parlor is renowned for its mouth-watering pies, friendly staff, and cozy atmosphere.

If you’re looking for a fantastic Belmar restaurant with delicious pizza piled high with toppings, Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant is the place to go. You’ll enjoy the spacious dining area, vibrant atmosphere, and wallet-friendly prices. This restaurant has an extensive selection of Italian-inspired dishes, from fully loaded submarine sandwiches to healthy salads and homemade soups.

If you’re searching for an extraordinary culinary experience, Chicken Calabrese might be the perfect poultry-based pasta dish to try. This exquisite meal consists of roasted peppers, a white wine garlic sauce, succulent sauteed chicken, and spinach.

For something just as delectable to share with your group, order one of their specialty thick-crust pizzas – the Pizza Provolone is particularly delicious! The pizza is adorned with olive oil, chopped onions, plum tomatoes, provolone cheese, parmesan cheese, and various spices.

700 Main St
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 681-6936

The Buttered Biscuit

The Buttered Biscuit, a cafe that opened in 2011, is well-known for its delicious New American breakfast specialties. It offers a range of gourmet breakfast dishes made with locally sourced ingredients and served in a warm ambiance. With its attentive service and flavorful fare, The Buttered Biscuit is the perfect place to start your day!

The Buttered Biscuit is just one of the many local eateries that provide a wonderful brunch experience for you and your companions. Its inviting atmosphere, cozy seating, bright lighting, and inventive menu items make it a great spot to enjoy a meal together.

Maui Meg’s has an interesting take on a traditional brunch item – French Toast! Their version features grilled banana bread served with toasted coconuts and crushed macadamia nuts from Hawaii. Daddy Dave’s Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich is also worth sampling!

700 Main St
Bradley Beach, NJ 07720
(732) 807-4069

La Dolce Vita

Indulge in the exquisite flavors of traditional Italian cuisine while taking in the breathtaking oceanfront views at La Dolce Vita. Enjoy a luxurious evening of fine dining and impeccable service that can only be found at this elegant establishment. Let La Dolce Vita provide an unforgettable night out and savor the delicious delicacies that make it one of Belmar’s most renowned restaurants.

This remarkable restaurant has spectacular windows that provide awe-inspiring views of the Atlantic Ocean and a patio for outdoor dining. It serves generous portions and its full-service bar provides drinks to accompany any meal. Catering services are also available for exclusive private events.

If you’re looking for something light but flavorful for lunch, try their Salmon Belmar salad – it’s sure to be a delicious treat! Try a scrumptious, in-house crafted pasta dish like Orecchiette Alla Barese. It is made with cherry tomatoes, shrimp, sautéed broccoli rabe, olive oil, sweet Italian sausage, garlic, and white wine sauce.

400 N Ocean Ave
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 749-3177


Established in 2006, this New Orleans eatery has a unique atmosphere and offers an array of delectable Creole and Cajun-style dishes that will satisfy any appetite. So come by Clementines the next time you are in the area to enjoy a great meal!

This old-fashioned bistro has a laid-back atmosphere and offers an extensive selection of high-end meals. The accommodating staff is sure to make you feel welcome. To experience a delicious red meat dish, try the Veal Clementine – bowtie pasta paired with pan-fried veal, a velvety sauce, tasso ham, and shrimp.

Satisfy your love for seafood by trying the Seafood Jambalaya Pasta. It’s made with angel hair pasta, shrimp, crawfish, spinach, parmesan, scallops, Cajun sausages, and a Creole cream sauce.

306 Main St
Avon-By-The-Sea, NJ 07717
(732) 988-7979

St. Stephen’s Green Publick House

St. Stephen’s Green Publick House is ideal for a unique dining experience. Located less than five minutes from the beach, it is an Irish pub and restaurant where you can savor quality fare made with fresh ingredients in a cozy atmosphere. Enjoy classic Irish dishes and traditional American favorites like burgers and sandwiches while washing it down with one of the many beers on tap.

This magnificent restaurant has an energetic atmosphere, serving up traditional Irish dishes with cozy decor and live music on selected evenings. If you’re looking for a crowd-pleaser, you can’t go wrong with the Guinness Beef Stew – a hearty dish made up of sirloin cubes, potatoes, carrots, celery, onions, and other vegetables cooked in a rich Guinness beer sauce.

For the perfect accompaniment to your beverage, why not try the Wolfhound? It’s sure to become a favorite, featuring mouthwatering buttered, toasted rolls with coleslaw and succulent Irish whiskey barbecue-flavored pork.

2031 NJ-71
Spring Lake, NJ 07762
(732) 449-2626

9th Avenue Pier

The renowned 9th Avenue Pier is a beloved American restaurant that has delighted customers for years. Located on the picturesque banks of the Shark River, this establishment provides an idyllic setting for lunch, dinner, or simply drinks with friends. Boasting a wide selection of delicious dishes and beverages, it’s no wonder why this eatery is so popular amongst locals and visitors alike. With its stunning views of the river, friendly staff, and incredible cuisine, it’s easy to see why the 9th Avenue Pier remains one of America’s most cherished restaurants.

Do you crave a savory, hand-held meal that will tantalize your taste buds? If so, we highly recommend trying the Oklahoma Onion Burger. This classic dish consists of two ground beef patties, melt-in-your-mouth American cheese, crunchy pickles, and thin slices of onions that bring out the flavors of this delicious burger.

Make healthier choices with the Coconut Shrimp Salad. It’s made with fresh greens, feta cheese, onions, champagne vinaigrette dressing, coconut shrimp, craisins, tomatoes and craisins for a delicious experience.

905 Highway 35
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 749-3800

10th Ave. Burrito

The 10th Ave. Burrito is a lively and bustling dining establishment serving an array of Mexican and Californian cuisine. Customers flock here to enjoy the fresh and flavorful dishes, which include everything from tacos and burritos to enchiladas and quesadillas. A favorite among locals, this restaurant is renowned for its friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and delicious food.

Take the opportunity to reconnect with your family, friends, or special someone while enjoying a delicious lunch at 10th Ave. Burrito in Belmar! Not only does this eatery provide an impressive selection of tequilas and a wide variety of Mexican-California fusion cuisine, but it also promises you a truly remarkable experience.

Vegetarians should try out The Dirty Hippie Tacos, a delicious meal featuring tofu, onions, tomatoes, lime, black beans, cilantro, and garlic with a side salad. Taste a flavorful meal, such as the Blackened Seafood Burrito. This dish includes pineapple salsa, chipotle sour cream, beans, avocados, and spinach.

801 Belmar Plaza
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 280-1515

Alternative Plate

For roughly a quarter of a century, The Alternative Plate has been an outstanding eatery for vegans in Belmar. This restaurant was founded to provide plant-based ingredients to create delicious and nutritious meals for those who follow vegan diets and it’s one of the most acclaimed restaurants in Belmar.

The Alternative Plate allows diners to enjoy flavorful dishes without compromising their dietary restrictions or preferences.

If you’re hunting for Belmar eats, The Alternative Plate is your go-to spot for the most scrumptious plant-based fare. Boasting food made from organic ingredients of the highest quality, stylish minimalist decor, and friendly staff, this is one eatery you won’t want to miss.

1300 Main St Box 55
Belmar, NJ 07719
(732) 552-3319